How Commercial Net Effective Rent & NPV Concession Analysis Works
In office, medical, retail, and industrial leasing, headline base rents rarely tell the full economic story. A tenant proposing $34.00/SqFt/yr with 3 months of abated rent and a $35.00/SqFt Tenant Improvement (TI) allowance can deliver a dramatically lower real return to the landlord than a clean renewal at $30.00/SqFt with zero TI. Calculating Net Effective Rent (NER) reduces every lease proposal to an objective, apples-to-apples annual yield per square foot.
The Complete Net Effective Rent Formulas
2. Undiscounted Net Effective Rent = (Net Cash Rent − TI Allowance − Brokerage Commission) ÷ (RSF × Term Years)
3. Deal NPV = Σm=1..N [ Net Cashm ÷ (1 + rm)m ] − (TI + Commission)
4. NPV Net Effective Rent ($/SqFt/Yr) = [ Deal NPV × CRF(rm, N) × 12 ] ÷ RSF
Worked Example: 4,500 RSF Office Lease (60 Months @ $34.00/SqFt, 3% Escalation)
Consider a 5-year (60-month) lease for 4,500 SqFt starting at $34.00/SqFt/yr ($12,750.00/mo) with 3.0% annual bumps, 3 months free rent ($38,250.00), $35.00/SqFt TI ($157,500.00), and a 4.0% leasing commission ($30,961.91) evaluated at a 7.5% annual discount rate:
| Metric | Formula Basis | Total Dollars | Annual $/SqFt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross Scheduled Base Rent (Years 1–5) | 3.0% Annual Escalation | $812,297.78 | $36.10 / SqFt |
| Less Free Rent Abatement (Months 1–3) | 3.0 × $12,750.00 | −$38,250.00 | −$1.70 / SqFt |
| GAAP Straight-Line Rent (ASC 842) | Net Cash Rent ÷ 5 Yrs ÷ 4,500 | $774,047.78 | $34.40 / SqFt |
| Less Upfront TI Allowance & 4% Commission | $157,500 TI + $30,961.91 Comm | −$188,461.91 | −$8.38 / SqFt |
| Undiscounted Net Effective Rent | Net Cash After All Concessions | $585,585.87 | $26.03 / SqFt |
Commercial Lease Structuring & Concession Best Practices
- Amortizing Excess TI Above Market: When a tenant requests above-standard buildout dollars, landlords frequently structure the additional TI as an amortized loan component over the initial term at 8%–10% interest rather than absorbing it into base rent.
- Clawback Clauses on Unamortized Concessions: Commercial leases should stipulate that if a tenant defaults early, any unamortized free rent, TI allowance, and leasing commission become immediately due alongside mitigated rent damages.
- Pure NNN vs. Full-Service Gross: Notice that Net Effective Rent isolates base rent economics. Under a Triple-Net (NNN) lease, operating expenses pass through separately; under a Full-Service Gross lease, subtract estimated OpEx per SqFt to compare on a true NNN-equivalent basis.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Face Rent and Net Effective Rent in a commercial lease?
Face Rent is the headline annual base rent per square foot stated in the lease or LOI (for example, $34.00/SqFt/yr). Net Effective Rent subtracts the amortized cost of landlord concessions—such as abated free-rent months, Tenant Improvement (TI) allowances, and brokerage commissions—to reveal the landlord's true economic yield per square foot per year.
How does NPV Net Effective Rent differ from simple straight-line Effective Rent?
Simple straight-line Net Effective Rent divides total net cash flow evenly over the lease term without accounting for the time value of money. Because TI allowances and leasing commissions are paid upfront at lease signing while escalated rent arrives years later, NPV Net Effective Rent discounts all monthly cash flows at the owner's cost of capital and converts the NPV into an equivalent annual annuity.
How are free-rent months treated under ASC 842 straight-line lease accounting?
Under GAAP ASC 842, total contractual base rent payments (after deducting abated free-rent periods) are summed over the entire non-cancellable lease term and divided evenly across every month of occupancy, creating a uniform monthly straight-line rent figure.
Should leasing commissions be included in Net Effective Rent comparisons?
Yes, for landlord investment underwriting. When comparing a renewal (often 2% to 3% commission and minimal TI) against a new third-party tenant (4% to 6% commission and full TI buildout), including commissions reveals why retaining an existing tenant at a slightly lower face rent often produces higher Net Effective Rent.